Wednesday, January 11, 2006
Books and Culture Magazine on Mormonism

The January/February 2006 issue of Books and Culture includes two book reviews on Mormonism: The Rise of Mormonism by Rodney Stark, and Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling by Richard Lyman Bushman (my review of this book is available in a previous post). Both are now available online.

Gerald R. McDermott reviews The Rise of Mormonism in "
Saints Rising: Is Mormonism the first new world religion since the birth of Islam?". Stark, the author of the book, is the scholar who made the famous claim that the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints will soon become the next world religion (comparable to that of Hinduism, Buddhism, Judaism, Christianity, Islam, etc.). This prediction is renewed in his latest book. McDermott responds with a certain amount of skepticism, seeking to assess the likelihood of Starks' prediction. While McDermott believes that it is possible, he also sees some serious obstacles. His interaction with Stark is helpful (even if I do not hold to McDermott's optimism regarding the relationship between Mormonism and historic Christianity).

In the same issue, Laurie F. Maffly-Kipp reviews Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling in "
Who's That on the $50 Bill? Placing Joseph Smith in America's story." She assesses Bushman's biography in light of the author's goals, which she summarizes in the following way:

Bushman, equally at home within the university and the Mormon tabernacle, has three essential goals in this work. First, he seeks to explore faithfully the story of Joseph Smith's life. He attempts, in his words, "to think as Smith thought" in an effort to explain his actions and the development of the Mormon movement between 1820 and 1844. Second, Bushman strives to present an apologia to a secular (and most often hostile) world. Thus, he labors to convey the reasonableness, coherence, and historicity of Smith's doctrinal world. Finally, Bushman wants to legitimate Smith's importance beyond the Mormon world by situating him within a pantheon of American icons, as well as within broader intellectual currents of Western civilization. Bushman wants to make Joseph Smith more than Mormon.

Does Bushman accomplish his goals? Maffly-Kipp gives a mixed answer. She also points to the historiographical problem that Bushman strives to overcome in his work. Seeking to straddle the sacred/secular divide in his approach to Joseph Smith, Bushman argues for both sides. As Maffly-Kipp says, "Bushman would, I suspect, say that Smith was both a genius and divinely inspired, and was engaged in different revelatory modes from pure revelation to milder inspiration." She criticizes this conclusion, seeing no reason to support Bushman's distinctions. I agree, and I find Maffly-Kipp's review insightful.

posted at 9:13 AM  
Comments (0)


Post a Comment

<< Home

About Me


I am a former Mormon who has been saved by Jesus Christ. Now I am a missionary involved with the Africa Center for Apologetics Research (ACFAR). I seek to live in light of Paul's words: "For to me to live is Christ, and to die is gain." (Philippians 1:21 ESV)

My Complete Profile

About My Blog
  • Why I am the Reformed Baptist Thinker

  • Recent Posts
  • My Departure from the A-Team

  • Book Review: Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling

  • CD Review: Awesome God

  • Emerging Clarification

  • What Can We Expect From Emergent in 2006?

  • Is There More Aslan in Kong Than in Disney's Narni...

  • More on Evangelicals and the Movies

  • How Should Evangelicals Witness to Mormons?

  • Evangelicals and the Movies

  • The Importance of Blogging

  • Reformed Links
  • The 1689 London Baptist Confession of Faith
  • The Association of Reformed Baptist Churches in America
  • Discerning Reader
  • Founders Ministries
  • The Gospel Coalition
  • Monergism
  • Nicene Council
  • The Reformed Baptist Theological Review
  • Reformation 21
  • The Spurgeon Archive
  • Third Millennium Ministries
  • Together for the Gospel
  • John Frame and Vern Poythress
  • Sam Waldron

  • Apologetics Links
  • Mormonism Research Ministry
  • Truth in Love Ministry
  • Centers for Apologetics Research
  • LifeWay Apologetics
  • Alpha and Omega Ministries

  • Blogroll
  • The A-Team Blog
  • Illumination
  • Mormon Coffee
  • Pros Apologian
  • Pulpit Magazine
  • Pyromaniacs
  • Reformation 21 Blog
  • Reformed Baptist Fellowship
  • Said at Southern
  • Together for the Gospel Blog
  • Tom Ascol
  • Les Bollinger
  • Denny Burk
  • Tim Challies
  • Steve Cowan
  • Jeff Downs
  • Bob Kauflin
  • Kevin Larson
  • Albert Mohler Commentary
  • Albert Mohler Blog
  • Russell Moore
  • Jonathan Moorhead
  • Matt Perry
  • David Sills
  • Justin Taylor
  • Brent Thomas
  • Joe Thorn
  • Paul Tripp
  • Keith Walker

  • Labels
  • Apologetics
  • Book Reviews
  • Christianity and Culture
  • Emerging Church and Postmodernism
  • Missions
  • Mormonism
  • Puritans
  • Theology
  • "Weird Al" Yankovic
  • Personal Life
  • Personal Ministry
  • Other Resources

  • Miscellaneous

    Subscribe to Reformed Baptist Thinker

  • December 2005

  • January 2006

  • February 2006

  • March 2006

  • April 2006

  • May 2006

  • June 2006

  • July 2006

  • August 2006

  • September 2006

  • October 2006

  • November 2006

  • December 2006

  • January 2007

  • February 2007

  • March 2007

  • April 2007

  • May 2007

  • June 2007

  • July 2007

  • August 2007

  • September 2007

  • October 2007

  • November 2007

  • December 2007

  • March 2008

  • Credits
    Blog Design by:

    Powered by:

    Image from: