Tuesday, January 10, 2006
Book Review: Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling

December 23, 2005 was the two hundredth anniversary of the birth of Joseph Smith, the founder of Mormonism. In light of his bicentennial, historian Richard Lyman Bushman has released a massive biography—Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling. Weighing in at 740 pages, this book is one of the most comprehensive investigations into the life of Joseph Smith to date. It will undoubtedly become a standard reference for the life of a great American enigma.

Why is this true? Because Bushman's work is filled with thorough research. This author has done his homework, and it shows. He constantly refers to relevant sources, including many primary and original source materials. The result is a very detailed look at Smith's life.

At the same time, this tome is also well written. Even with its thoroughness, it is easy to read. Bushman is telling a story of the man who began what has become an entrenched American religion. The reader easily becomes immersed into Smith's world and culture. As a result, the pages pass quickly. You want to read what happens next.

Unfortunately, Bushman is not always a reliable guide. This quote is telling:

Incredible as the [gold] plates were, hunting for deception can be a distraction. It throws us off the track of Joseph Smith the Prophet. In devising a story of a charlatan, we lose sight of the unprepossessing rural visionary who became a religious leader admired by thousands. What is most interesting about Joseph Smith is that people believed him. To understand the emergence of Joseph the Prophet, we must follow the stories told by family and friends who believed they were witnessing a miracle. From their accounts issues the Joseph Smith who has a place in history (58).

So then, Bushman feels free to divorce Smith's history from his legacy. What matters is the Joseph Smith known and loved by his followers, not necessarily the actual, historical man. Discerning readers cannot help but wonder if the story they are reading is accurate.

Bushman dismisses critics and criticism far too easily. He does not sufficiently wrestle with historical difficulties. While he does admit mistakes and flaws in Smith, he does not entertain the possibility that Smith could be anything other than what he claimed to be, a restoring prophet of God. We may expect this treatment from a practicing Mormon, but his lack of interaction with critical sources leaves his narrative unconvincing.

The author's bias is particularly noticeable when he deals with the historicity of Latter-day Saint scriptures (such as the Book of Mormon and the Book of Abraham) as well as Smith's polygamy. Chapter four, "A New Bible," reads like a rehashing of arguments from BYU apologists at FARMS. His division of plural marriage from polygamy rings artificial and leads to an implausible reconstruction of the emerging practice among the Saints.

Therefore, Bushman's biography is an immensely helpful yet insufficient account of Joseph Smith. When used critically, it promises to be a valuable resource. But as a historical work on Joseph Smith, it leaves much to be desired.

Labels: ,

posted at 2:45 PM  
Comments (2)

At 4:04 PM, Blogger Genevieve said...

I am probably going to buy this book as a birthday gift for my husband. He was brought up RLDS and is now a Lutheran. He has read nearly every book that has ever been written about Joseph Smith, so he will be greatly interested in this new biography. I enjoyed reading your review of it. May God bless your studies and ministry.

At 6:11 PM, Blogger Pat said...

I have just found your blog and hope that you will continue to write posts and updates. You haven't stopped have you?

My PAD and
Guelph Daily Photo


Post a Comment

<< Home

About Me


I am a former Mormon who has been saved by Jesus Christ. Now I am a missionary involved with the Africa Center for Apologetics Research (ACFAR). I seek to live in light of Paul's words: "For to me to live is Christ, and to die is gain." (Philippians 1:21 ESV)

My Complete Profile

About My Blog
  • Why I am the Reformed Baptist Thinker

  • Recent Posts
  • CD Review: Awesome God

  • Emerging Clarification

  • What Can We Expect From Emergent in 2006?

  • Is There More Aslan in Kong Than in Disney's Narni...

  • More on Evangelicals and the Movies

  • How Should Evangelicals Witness to Mormons?

  • Evangelicals and the Movies

  • The Importance of Blogging

  • What is "Official" Mormon Doctrine? (Part 3)

  • What is "Official" Mormon Doctrine? (Part 2)

  • Reformed Links
  • The 1689 London Baptist Confession of Faith
  • The Association of Reformed Baptist Churches in America
  • Discerning Reader
  • Founders Ministries
  • The Gospel Coalition
  • Monergism
  • Nicene Council
  • The Reformed Baptist Theological Review
  • Reformation 21
  • The Spurgeon Archive
  • Third Millennium Ministries
  • Together for the Gospel
  • John Frame and Vern Poythress
  • Sam Waldron

  • Apologetics Links
  • Mormonism Research Ministry
  • Truth in Love Ministry
  • Centers for Apologetics Research
  • LifeWay Apologetics
  • Alpha and Omega Ministries

  • Blogroll
  • The A-Team Blog
  • Illumination
  • Mormon Coffee
  • Pros Apologian
  • Pulpit Magazine
  • Pyromaniacs
  • Reformation 21 Blog
  • Reformed Baptist Fellowship
  • Said at Southern
  • Together for the Gospel Blog
  • Tom Ascol
  • Les Bollinger
  • Denny Burk
  • Tim Challies
  • Steve Cowan
  • Jeff Downs
  • Bob Kauflin
  • Kevin Larson
  • Albert Mohler Commentary
  • Albert Mohler Blog
  • Russell Moore
  • Jonathan Moorhead
  • Matt Perry
  • David Sills
  • Justin Taylor
  • Brent Thomas
  • Joe Thorn
  • Paul Tripp
  • Keith Walker

  • Labels
  • Apologetics
  • Book Reviews
  • Christianity and Culture
  • Emerging Church and Postmodernism
  • Missions
  • Mormonism
  • Puritans
  • Theology
  • "Weird Al" Yankovic
  • Personal Life
  • Personal Ministry
  • Other Resources

  • Miscellaneous

    Subscribe to Reformed Baptist Thinker

  • December 2005

  • January 2006

  • February 2006

  • March 2006

  • April 2006

  • May 2006

  • June 2006

  • July 2006

  • August 2006

  • September 2006

  • October 2006

  • November 2006

  • December 2006

  • January 2007

  • February 2007

  • March 2007

  • April 2007

  • May 2007

  • June 2007

  • July 2007

  • August 2007

  • September 2007

  • October 2007

  • November 2007

  • December 2007

  • March 2008

  • Credits
    Blog Design by:

    Powered by:

    Image from: